Skip to content
Sunday, November 8, 2026
A blog dedicated to uncovering silent topics in society, cu…

Which Players Has Made Troy's Top-Flight Weekly Best XI?

Following every set of Premier League matches during the current campaign, BBC football pundit Troy Deeney selects his team and boss of the week.

Take a look at this week's picks. Do you agree? Share your feedback.

The Goalkeeper

Jordan Pickford (Everton): A crucial play in the Toffees' comprehensive victory against Chelsea was his superb stop to prevent a goal from Enzo Fernandez. He has stepped up in a major way in those situations for Everton throughout the campaign and, fans will hope, he can continue for the national team in the summer World Cup. Just last week, he committed a costly mistake versus Arsenal but has picked himself up again to perform for the Toffees.

Defensive Unit

Neco Williams (Nottingham Forest): It shaped up as a huge pivotal match for Forest away at Tottenham, with Premier League status hanging in the balance for each team. And Williams put in a massive display to help his side secure a vital three points in the battle against the drop. He bagged two key passes, delivering when it counted.

Matty Cash (Aston Villa): In my view, West Ham provided a significant threat going forward but Cash remained resolute and kept things together for Villa. He was able to just keeping the play moving. He provided a lot going forward and simultaneously snuff out everything the Hammers attempted in attack.

James Tarkowski (Everton): It constituted yet another assured performance from the Toffees defender. He demonstrated his composure and control, and consistently positionally perfect. He executed key challenges when required and, crucially, served as a steadying presence in their backline. How Chelsea must wish for a central defender with such determination, particularly given the uncertain defending they have exhibited at times.

The Midfielders

Chris Rigg (Sunderland): It was a solid performance from Rigg in a memorable Tyne-Wear derby. He did not do anything extraordinary against Newcastle but he performed everything exceptionally competently. With Rigg, you are aware of the level of performance from him.

James Garner (Everton): He easily could have just chilled out after getting called up to the England squad this week. But instead, he cracked on and delivered a great performance. It was a exquisite assist from him to Beto for Everton's first goal. As a former teammate with him at Watford, I know he's all about relentless work rate and big tackles. He has got it all and I am confident he performs for England to earn a place into that World Cup final roster.

John McGinn (Aston Villa): He's their captain, leader and key figure. It's amounted to two enormous displays in the course of a week from him. Villa can be considered a respectable team. But McGinn makes them a exceptional one. If they are to secure the Champions League places and challenge for the European title, they require him to keep producing at this level.

Harry Wilson (Fulham): He has made a tendency of getting big goals and he did exactly that once more this week. I wonder how they can possibly find a replacement if he opts to leave. They are unlikely to invest a huge sum on somebody with his qualities. They require him to put pen to paper on a renewal as he is a massively key component of that Cottagers set-up.

The Attack

Bruno Fernandes (Manchester United): It feels like the Portuguese playmaker is turning into a staple in the team of the week. You must include him once again following a further goal, and also causing the James Hill own goal. How long will United stay mediocre and retain his services before he decides it is the right moment to leave the club?

Beto (Everton): This week, we have a pair of strikers who are at very different points in their career. I am uncertain Beto is a long-term answer for the Merseyside club's attacking woes, but boss David Moyes is getting the best out of him currently. It is notable given how subpar he was in the initial months.

Danny Welbeck (Brighton): He was overlooked by the England manager once more for the national team, at a point when they need back-up to captain Harry Kane. But Welbeck proceeded to deliver for the Seagulls with a double, to overcome reigning champions Liverpool, and increase his total to 12 goals for the campaign.

The Dugout Doyen

David Moyes (Everton): The fixture between Everton and Chelsea was a textbook example of traditional against new school. Blues boss Liam Rosenior is attempting to establish himself at the outset of his managerial career but Moyes devised a flawless tactical plan to secure a dominant result. The Toffees were more assertive and stronger in each area of the game and it was a massive win for them.

Do you agree with Deeney's selections? Which players would make up your Team of the Week? Have your say.

Written by

Christopher Knight

A sociologist and writer passionate about uncovering societal taboos and fostering open dialogue through insightful analysis.

Silent Topics

Type to search articles.